Is the letter of credit suitable for today's requirements: advantages and disadvantages

‍

In international trade, the letter of credit remains one of the most widely used financial instruments for securing transactions between exporters and importers. This payment method, which involves banks as intermediaries, provides a structured framework for cross-border exchanges. However, before adopting the letter of credit, its advantages and disadvantages deserve examination, particularly in the age of digitalization.

‍

The traditional operation of the letter of credit

The letter of credit represents a commitment made by a bank, at the request of the buyer (importer), to pay the seller (exporter) a specified amount, provided that the latter submits compliant documents within a specific timeframe. This mechanism acts as a safety net for both parties involved. However, a clear understanding of this process is essential to assess the relevance of the letter of credit, its advantages and disadvantages, in the context of international business.

For the importer, the letter of credit guarantees that payment will only be made if the specified conditions are met. For the exporter, it constitutes a payment guarantee that significantly reduces commercial risk.

‍

Undeniable assets: the main advantages of the letter of credit

Examining the letter of credit, its advantages and disadvantages, reveals several substantial benefits for international trade participants.

Enhanced security for all parties

One of the main advantages of the letter of credit is the protection it offers against the risks inherent in international transactions. For the exporter, it represents a payment assurance, effectively reducing the risk of non-payment. For the importer, it ensures that documents certifying the conformity of the goods will be verified before any disbursement.

Global acceptance

Letters of credit are universally recognized and accepted. They provide a standardized framework for commercial exchanges, regardless of the countries involved. This global recognition allows businesses to conduct transactions with a certain confidence in the process, especially when working with emerging markets or new business partners.

Notable flexibility

Letters of credit offer a degree of flexibility. Their terms can be customized according to the specific transaction and provide for different variations, including revocable and irrevocable, confirmed and unconfirmed letters of credit, as well as options for sight or deferred payment.

‍

Major drawbacks: the downside of the letter of credit

However, when it comes to letters of credit, significant advantages and disadvantages coexist, limiting its effectiveness in the current business environment.

Considerable administrative complexity

Setting up a letter of credit involves numerous administrative steps and the meticulous preparation of multiple documents. This complexity can be particularly daunting for SMEs that do not have international trade experts. The advantages and disadvantages of the letter of credit must therefore be carefully assessed based on the administrative resources available within the company.

The slightest error in the documentation can lead to significant delays or even a refusal of payment, and discrepancies in the documents can complicate the transaction process.

Significant costs to consider

Letters of credit involve costs such as issuance, amendment, and negotiation fees. These expenses can accumulate quickly, particularly weighing on small and medium-sized enterprises.

For SMEs that conduct medium or low-volume transactions, these costs can represent a significant financial burden and impact their competitiveness.

Problematic processing times

Despite their aim of securing transactions, letters of credit sometimes cause delays. These delays can be a significant drawback in a business environment where speed has become paramount. Discrepancies in documents or other complications can lengthen the processes, impacting the pace of commercial transactions.

‍

When to favor the letter of credit despite its drawbacks

Despite the limitations mentioned, the letter of credit (with its advantages and disadvantages properly weighed) remains a relevant tool in certain specific contexts.

For high-risk transactions

When transactions involve unknown business partners or countries with political or economic instability, the letter of credit offers a level of protection that is difficult to match. In these contexts, its advantages in terms of security can largely compensate for its administrative and financial drawbacks.

For high-value transactions

For transactions involving significant amounts, the costs associated with the letter of credit represent proportionally a smaller burden. The protection it offers can then be considered a reasonable investment given the sums at stake and the potential risks.

Innovative solutions: emerging alternatives

Faced with the limitations of traditional letters of credit, new solutions are emerging to meet the contemporary demands of international trade. These alternatives aim to preserve the security advantages while reducing the disadvantages related to administrative complexity and costs.

Alternative payment guarantees

New payment guarantee mechanisms now provide alternatives to traditional letters of credit. These alternatives are particularly useful for securing funds during the transaction.

For example, some systems use segregated accounts where funds are held and blocked until all parties have met the requirements of the contract, providing similar protection with less administrative complexity.

Short-term financing as a supplement

Short-term financing solutions can effectively complement payment guarantee arrangements. They offer flexible terms that can range from 30 to 120 days.

These financing options can help businesses optimize their cash flow management by relieving the constraint of immediate payments. For exporters, this represents an improvement in cash flow, while importers can use them to align payment deadlines with their revenue cycles.

‍

The letter of credit remains an effective security instrument for certain international transactions, but its limitations are becoming increasingly evident in a business environment that demands speed and agility. By weighing the advantages and disadvantages of the letter of credit, businesses can determine whether this tool meets their specific needs or whether it is appropriate to explore alternatives.

‍